A Holiday Recipe Favorite… Potato Casserole Supreme!

A Holiday Recipe Favorite… Potato Casserole Supreme!

This recipe yields 15 buffet servings; double as needed!
5 pounds of potatoes (Yukon Gold or red-skinned)
½ cup butter
1 ½ tsp salt
¼ tsp pepper
1 cup warm whole milk (Microwave about 2 min. Don’t skip this step; you will always need more than 1 cup milk!)
1 cup shredded cheddar cheese
1 cup heavy cream, whipped
Peel and dice potatoes; boil until tender in lightly salted water.
Add about 2tsp of white vinegar to the water to make the potatoes very white.
Drain potatoes and combine with butter, salt, pepper and milk in large bowl of electric mixer; beat until smooth and creamy.
Check seasonings; turn into buttered shallow casserole.
Fold cheese into whipped cream and spread over potatoes.
Bake at 350 F for about 30 minutes, until golden brown and heated through.
Potatoes may be prepared ahead of time…the topping added just before baking!
1. It may take more milk to get the right creaminess. It’s never taken less! Potatoes vary in texture, moisture content etc. so make adjustments as needed. (Warm milk for best results)
2. Taste to be sure there’s enough salt and pepper.
3. You can make the potato casserole a day ahead (including the topping) and refrigerate.
4. Important: Bring to room temp before baking!
5. Two recipes (5 pounds of potatoes per recipe) is plenty for a gathering of 30 people!

Leave a comment

Smile Advatange

Schedule your next dental appointment with us today!


Our practice is committed to providing you and your family with safe, gentle, high-quality dental care. We are sensitive to your needs, and it is our goal to make you feel comfortable visiting our practice while providing the best care possible.

Our Location

Contact us

(727) 581-1441

Monday - Thursday: 8am -5pm

2127 NE Coachman Rd
Clearwater, FL 33765

  • Follow Us:

Copyright 2018 © Andrew J. Holloman, DDS & Associates
Privacy Policy | Accessibility Policy